Environmental Stress Testing
The objective of the pilot project on Environmental Stress Testing was to develop and test an innovative analytical framework and open-source tool that allow banks to assess the potential impact of drought events on the performance of their corporate loan portfolio. Typically, financial institutions lack respective instruments and capacities. The Drought Stress Testing Tool enables banks to assess if a client may be at risk from drought and how drought can affect a sector or region. A clearer understanding of the risk associated with droughts can help build stronger resilience by:
- re-allocating core capital to less vulnerable sectors and regions,
- increasing the funding costs for water-sensitive, resource-intensive sectors,
- enhance the dialogue between financial institutions and their clients with respect to resource-efficient and drought resilient business models and technologies.
Consequently, this translates into more sustainable economies and financial systems as well as healthier ecosystems better equipped to absorb shocks such as droughts.
Based on the catastrophe modelling framework that the insurance industry has used for 25 years, the developed framework and tool look at five drought scenarios in four countries – Brazil, China, Mexico and the US – to model the impact on 19 different industry sectors, the companies in those sectors and the likelihood that they will default on their loans.
The project was implemented in partnership with nine banks from across the globe, which tested the tool on a sample of their corporate loan portfolio as showcased in the project report Drought Stress Testing – Making Financial Institutions more Resilient to Environmental Risks. The partner banks, which represent more than USD 10 trillion in assets under management, comprise:
- Banorte (Mexico)
- Caixa Econômica Federal (Brazil)
- Citibanamex (Mexico)
- Citigroup (U.S.)
- Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) (China)
- Itaú Unibanco (Brazil)
- Santander (Brazil)
- Trust Funds for Rural Development (FIRA) (Mexico)
- UBS (Switzerland/U.S.)
Key findings from the report include:
- Extreme droughts could increase loan default losses ten-fold for specific portfolios that are most exposed to the effects of drought;
- Even when exposed to less extreme drought scenarios, most companies in the analyzed portfolios see their credit ratings downgraded;
- The most affected sectors are water supply, agriculture and, in countries with high reliance upon hydroelectric energy, power generation;
- Significant impacts are also found in water-dependent sectors such as food and beverage production;
- Sectors that are less water-dependent but highly sensitive to general macroeconomic conditions, such as petroleum refining, are also affected by widespread economic impacts of drought.
Eric Usher, Head of UNEP FI, said: “Making the move to a sustainable finance system will require the development of innovative tools such as this. This is the first time drought risk has been assessed in this way, and the involvement of nine forward-thinking banks from around the world proves how serious global financial institutions are becoming about considering the risk from extreme environmental events such as drought.”
Courtney Lowrance, Global Head of Environmental and Social Risk Management at Citi said in the press release for the launch of the tool: “The development of the tool is timely, as it will inform how institutions can conduct scenario analysis on climate change risks in alignment with the expected guidance from the Taskforce on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures.”
Linda Murasawa, Sustainability Head of Santander Brazil noted: “This tool will have immediate impact in terms of awareness raising and bringing the issue of environmental stress testing closer to mainstream risk management.”
The project was financed by the German Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ), and developed jointly by the Natural Capital Financial Alliance (NCFA) and the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH. A consortium led by global risk modelling experts from Risk Management Solutions (RMS) designed, developed and implemented the tool and underlying framework.
Publications & Tool
The Excel-based tool is free to access and use, allowing financial analysts and other users to test the methodology with their own portfolios.
To access the tool, please email firstname.lastname@example.org.
An introduction to the tool
The methodology behind the tool
- Presentation of the drought stress testing tool at the 12th Asian Bond Markets Summit (16 Nov 2017, Singapore)
- EU Business @ Biodiversity of the DG Environment reports: Innovative stress testing tool helps banks understand risk of loan default driven by drought (18 Apr 2017)
- GlobalCapital reports on drought stress testing tool: Banks at risk from drought, reveals ground-breaking research (13 Apr 2017)
- Presentation of the tool at China’s 2nd Green Finance Committee Annual Conference (15 April 2017, Beijing)
- Launch of the Environmental Stress Testing tool and report at the Environmental Finance conference Water: Risk, Opportunity and Sustainability 2017 (5 Apr 2017, London)
- Launch of the Environmental Stress Testing tool and report in Mexico City (7 March 2017), São Paulo (10 March 2017), Beijing (14 March 2017) and New York (17 March 2017)
- Presentation of the Environmental Stress Testing Tool at the UNEP FI Global Roundtable (25 & 26 Oct 2016, Dubai)
- RMS presents the Environmental Stress Testing Model at the Responsible Investor’s Europe 2016 Conference (22 & 23 June 2016, London)
- Partner Banks Workshops (April 2016, Beijing, São Paulo, Mexico City, New York City) and Expert Council Meeting (24 May 2016, London)
- Expert Council Meeting (24 May 2016, London)
- Environmental Finance: Tool launched to measure drought impact on corporate loans (5 April 2017)
- Natural Capital Finance Alliance: Innovative Stress Testing Tool Helps Banks Understand Risk of Loan Default Driven By Drought (5 April 2017, London)
- UNEP Finance Initiative: Innovative New Tool Helps Banks Understand Risk of Loan Default Caused By Drought (5 April 2017, London)
- CIR Magazine reports on the environmental stress testing model (4 May 2016)
Financial Institution Partners